Jump to content

Fastidious

Members
  • Content Count

    159
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

Everything posted by Fastidious

  1. Fastidious

    Should Reflex Arena be free?

    Reflex wouldn't benefit from F2P currently because of this. What would all these F2P players play? Duel? Maybe a few would but it doesn't have mass appeal. Reflex doesn't have any stellar team modes to anchor F2P.
  2. Fastidious

    Base problems of team modes

    I didn't know there were so many technical issues with larger player numbers on a server. If that is the case then maybe team modes aren't even worth working on. That said I don't think they really worked on team modes much. They gave interviews saying how important it was but team lock was never a feature for about 2 years. Clearly not an important part of the game. One important distinction to make regarding team modes might be to admit duel and team modes require different design. The problem with basically everything AFPS lately is they are designed around duel, then team modes fail horribly and everyone is like "well it's an AFPS we knew no one would play it." Why not actually design gameplay around teamplay modes for once? Hell most AFPS can't even recognize team modes need higher ammo caps which is incredibly basic. Sure 25 max rockets or whatever might work in duel but it is shit in team modes where you might have 3-5+ enemies on a team. More targets need more ammo. The reason QW TDM was magic was because the teamplay was good and revolved around self-sacrifice which was very unique. There's a big difference between basic coordination tactical play (deathball, OW ult combos, etc) and making plays that might hurt your own direct power but indirectly help you by making the team stronger. When you do an aggressive attack in QW TDM, secure a kill which drops a strong weapon pack for a team mate it might be very risky. After the fight you then have to sit around and guard it for a team mate to take (even riskier!). The selfish play would be to take the pack (more ammo!) and run. You're more likely to live but your team will be weaker off and if you need help later your team mate won't have a good weapon. Those are the decisions and unique aspects which make teamplay magic work yet it only happens if there are sharp power differences (strong QW RL, RA, quad every minute, etc) and scarcity (hard to get ammo, 30s weapon respawns). No one would save a weapon in QC because everything respawns in 5s. If you look at PUBG (which is insanely popular, shockingly popular) at it's core it's one life deathmatch. Yet it shares many AFPS qualities. Items are tied to map spawns and while random certain areas are much more likely to spawn certain things. In PUBG team modes players make tough quick decisions and need to do that sacrifice play which might be very risky for themselves but helps their team. It's very random (item spawns, circle, etc) which makes more crazy shit happen but also means it is a less serious competitive game. Yet at this point I think most AFPS players would be more than willing to trade a little casualness if it guaranteed an actual player base worth a damn. I also strongly believe no AFPS is going to have strong player base without a good solid team mode (and no CA isn't it because it's too simple). Maybe someday an AFPS will actually give team modes the effort they require.
  3. Fastidious

    Widgets/Addons and what is considered cheating?

    Indeed. Was talking to a friend recently about this and I didn't realize it had gotten this bad. I don't even want to touch the game at this point. There is a big difference between customization and outright cheats. For those who don't know their Quake history it used to be common place back in the day to cheat with sounds replacing them in .pak files with timer sounds. Players shouldn't need to spend hours tweaking their setups to be competitive.
  4. Fastidious

    We need to talk about the state of the game.

    I'll be brutally honest this is why I've given up on Reflex. It will never have a large enough community to support team modes or even a good 24/7 FFA server. I don't think this is fixable now. Reflex botched all the big free press it had. The initial version was released too early without good netcode. The CTF release came out with one map of questionable quality. The recent release had an opportunity to push team modes again but instead we got too many match making options to guarantee no one plays anything but duel. I feel like team modes were mostly ignored during development in favor of duel (the game balance is duel focused too). For years teams modes were broken without the ability to lock teams. When Reflex was announced years ago I was hyped. I expected a hardcore AFPS and it is. The problem is Reflex is essentially CPM. That I was not expecting. I thought it would be a hardcore AFPS inspired by Quake/CPM but doing innovative new things. The only major gameplay innovation was item timers and let us be honest that was a debacle. The design I've heard rumors of with the stake gun sounded innovative but the general public never saw it. At the end of the day CPM has never been popular and never will be. It was designed by committee for political purposes to appease fans of Q1-Q2-Q3 while trying to bring them together. It didn't work back then and it isn't working now. CPM has no real weaknesses but I'd also say it has no real strengths. I actually think CPM was better when it had 100 damage fast rail. At least then it had an extreme and was absolutely brutal. Then CPM ended up like QL with everything over balanced into blandess. Reflex is similar. With Diabotical and QC coming soon I'm expecting one of them will fill the team void I've been looking for and Reflex will just be a memory. For the record I bought multiple copies and got friends to buy copies too. I ran a 2v2 league about two years ago. I more than did my part supporting and trying to make Reflex succeed but sometimes you have to acknowledge reality. While I had fun in Reflex it never had the magic I felt in QW TDM for instance. Most of that magic came from intense competitive team modes and the community around it. In PVP games players are the content and you need a critical mass of them to be sustainable.
  5. Fastidious

    Game Mode Problems

    Don't add weapon drop to TDM. It really cheapens TDM and makes it too easy. I feel the same way about power up dropping in any mode (even CTF). Just makes things too easy. Let players work some to build up or actually have teamplay please. It is much harder to have the right player in the right place at the right time with the right weapons/armor than for people to drop things for others at their convenience.
  6. Fastidious

    What's up with TDM

    I'm not a fan of powerup drop either as it negates control of powerups and puts more emphasis on armors, etc. It also disallows sacrifice plays to remove a powerup or means little if a player manage to neutralize a powerup yet their team retains control. The only mode I think powerup drop works in at all is FFA and even there I'd prefer no drop. As far as dropping of other things (weapons, ammo, heath, armor, anything!) I'm strongly against it. For instance with weapon drop it allows teams to optimize too easily and removes the specific geographical map ties weapons have to certain locations. If a map is designed so the weak side controls the RL for instance weapon drop will make their control of it much weaker. It is also cool to drop a fresh spawn a better weapon but again I think this snowballs too much and favors the team in control while hurting the weak team. Dropping of anything that allows players to live I'm against (QW style is suicide to drop back packs). It just allows too efficient play and removes control. Go watch some top level Q2 TDM matches. They train transfer across the whole map without players moving their control positions. There is something cool about this type of gameplay but I much prefer traditional TDM where the game flows and players must roam or rotate through items and positions. It makes TDM much more dynamic when movement is heavily tied to control and sweeping areas clear or raiding them for resources is required.
  7. Fastidious

    What's up with TDM

    It is no mystery. The game has no real ammo system in place. TDM requires an ammo system. Without an ammo system fast weapon respawn is required which means everyone will have lots of weapons and usually lots of ammo as well. Even 2v2 TDM is pretty sketchy right now.
  8. Fastidious

    Friendly reminder about CTF/TDM pickups

    That is why but maybe not exactly in the way you think about it. There is no casual CTF scene. Most players need to play that Team FFA to learn in an environment that is more suited to their skill level. Most players never have interest in competitive nor advance past this state of play. In years past players could join giant public CTF games where teams were like 12v12 or more. It was chaos but fun. Good public CTFers eventually wanted more and started joining the competitive or private pickup scenes. Trying to start players in pickup games is terrible. It is hard on everyone both the new players and veterans. I agree with all your points except this one. I have no interest playing against players who have years of experience playing on old maps. Nor do I want to replay maps I myself already played in past games. The map pool for Reflex CTF is a critical weakness. I'm just waiting to see how the game develops. Trying to force growth in CTF or any other mode is going to be an almost impossible task and extremely frustrating unless there is a good amount of players to draw upon. Currently Reflex doesn't have enough players to warrant any kind of competitive scene for TDM/CTF/etc.
  9. Fastidious

    Redesign proposal of burst gun

    Here is the original thread you are talking about... I'd hardly call byce and son! newbies or the fact I outscored them slightly a stomp. The BG was completely broken. It used to 60 dmg a hit, then it was slightly nerfed to 54 which is what it was when I posted about it. Now it does 30 dmg. If someone is coming after you with low health you can easily finish them with a BG shot or two even now. I wouldn't call that completely useless. I'm thrilled they aren't going to add a starter gun which is hitscan (I'd argue Reflex already has too much hitscan). That said until a lot of team modes are getting played it is hard to completely judge the BG.
  10. Fastidious

    Reflex 0.37.0 - Mostly eggplant

    ​One of the greatest things I always loved about Quake was how it remained relatively stable and unchanging. It was up to us as the players to counter each other's gameplay advancements with our own. It was a struggle and sometimes we felt X, Y or Z was broken or too strong but eventually players always found ways to make the game work. I think what you are seeing is how Quake players hate change because we play a lot and become familiar with our game over time. I know Reflex isn't Quake but I definitely think people will say a lot less when things are set in stone and not in a state of flux. Also when things are open to change people will try their hardest to get their own preferences implemented. When gameplay keeps changing (especially something as practice intensive as movement) it messes up our personal struggle to get better and we fucking hate that.
  11. Fastidious

    Execution vs Decision Making

    Here is an interesting side story, Recently it was admitted CS:GO pros are using adderall at pro lan tournaments. I'm not expert on drugs but based on what I read I think adderall would help with execution based tasks and stuff like reaction times. Given Reflex is even more execution heavy than CS:GO; is that the future for this game if it ends being competitive? All of us on uppers or adderall to compete? I have used caffeine to good effect in my past competitive AFPS history and it seems to help cause my reaction times go down. Part of it is I definitely think execution ability suffers with how many of these tournaments are run. They are marathon events. Even many Reflex tournaments are hours and hours long online. I've always preferred a season format where matches are spread out over weeks so you have time to prepare, practice and be fresh for every match.
  12. Fastidious

    Matchmaking System

    I think having team modes helps with match making especially for newer/lower skill players. For instance a team of skills such as player skill high, medium, medium vs low, high, high is probably a decent match. Or say low, low, high vs medium, medium, low as another example. However in duels there is not the same flexibility. Anyone not close in skill won't be a decent match. It is just the nature of duel and team modes. Hopefully we see some real work being done on CTF, TDM, or other major team modes soon. In all the draft leagues I took part in or spectated heavily (~15 seasons!) they worked because team modes allowed mix skill teams to be viable and competitive vs other mix skill teams. Team match making can work similarly. Perhaps some kind of mechanic with random captains and team picking in a lobby would be good in the short run as the best pickup communities I played in typically used these to their great benefit. The Reflex community is small enough where players would quickly become relatively known quantities about what you could expect from them in game. Once the game population grows more automatic match making can take over. Perhaps analyzing how the community captains picked their teams and how successful they were could even help with future match making.
  13. Fastidious

    Execution vs Decision Making

    ​I never said it was solved, however there are very few choices to make and usually most are straight forward. If you have superior execution skills often it is clear cut and there are no choices at all; unless you want to toy with your prey. AFPS seem to only be decent games when you are near evenly matched in execution skills which is a shame especially since such even matches are rare. Let us go back to what you said about Hal. ​I strongly agree with Hal. Execution is what determines how you can play. There is very little outside of that which has such a big impact on the game. I would rather the game was balanced so other game elements had a much larger impact. I wish items/etc for instance were completely changed so if I could control or manipulate them in certain ways I could beat someone who significantly out aims me. Such play was possible in the 90s but no additional mechanics have been added since then and the gameplay is now very well understood. Back then stratagems such as syncing items times or delaying items was not common except at higher levels of play. Average players know about all these tricks now along with general information such as item times. I just wish balance was changed so things such as decision making, teamplay, item control, etc could trump someone with "mad skills" (aka great execution).
  14. Fastidious

    Execution vs Decision Making

    ​In an effort to put this topic back on track I agree we need something new. We haven't seen anything truly new gameplay wise in Reflex yet and that scares me. I'd say Reflex has even been simplified with things such as no ammo packs. I like the concept of KISS but sometimes complexity is needed. Reflex would benefit from new gameplay which is not directly from CPMA, Quake, Painkiller, etc. I'm sure it would cause a big up roar and kick the trolls into over drive but I think change is needed. I think a lot of the weak decision making in AFPS as of late is due to how solved they are. Most of these games have close to pure solutions and have not changed much over the years. Mixed solutions are much more interesting and keep players adapting and reacting to each other much more. I also strongly believe making execution less of a dominant factor would be a massive improvement for most AFPS. In most AFPS if your execution skills are better you can ignore the rest of the gameplay which is beyond silly. You need not take items or armors if you can significantly out aim or move your opponent in a duel. I think AFPS pride themselves on how strong execution is in this genre but I also think it is a big reason no one plays these games anymore. There is no alternative to beat someone who hits 70% rail or 50% LG. Either you need to nearly match their aim or you lose. Other gameplay elements should matter and offer paths to victory. Decisions should be fuzzy and not a solved boring non-choice. Here is a related article which talks about pure solutions and mixed solutions: http://www.sirlin.net/articles/solvability I hope people take a few minutes to read it.
  15. Fastidious

    Partner$ in Crime Information/Results

    The playoff file seems to still work which is the most important. I'm not sure if the replays will even still play back (haven't tested it). Hopefully we will get some TDM/CTF/etc love soon and maybe we can do another teamplay focused NA league.
  16. I already posted this in a few places but now the league has officially started. Easiest way to report results is just reply to the thread here with screenshots linked. Just to clear things up, you can play out of order. The schedule below is just to give you an idea. Teams need to play each team in their group once by March 15th. Top two teams per group advance to playoffs. If you have questions fire me off a PM here on the forums or message me on Steam. I'd suggest contacting the teams you need to play and see when you can arrange a match time. Scheduling is flexible and up to the teams themselves. Teams could finish up all their matches tonight or wait till the last day (I don't recommend this!). Steam group - http://steamcommunity.com/groups/ReflexPIC Group 1 -kaiski/derazor/d3x -byce/Necrophag1st -lumiera/rline -null/procore Group 2 -rook/Fastidious -FFSmasher/v1ctor -ulty/griff -lonezilla/relay Group 3 -dustin/gramz -sane/grape/BlooD_DoG -eldrek/duster -xero/wonko Schedule (this is suggested only, you just need to play all 3 matches by end of week 2) Week 1 March 2nd - March 8th Group 1 kaiski/derazor/d3x vs byce/Necrophag1st lumiera/rline vs null/procore Group 2 rook/Fastidious vs FFSmasher/v1ctor ulty/griff vs lonezilla/relay Group 3 dustin/gramz vs sane/grape/BlooD_DoG eldrek/duster vs xero/wonko Week 2 March 9th - March 15th Group 1 kaiski/derazor/d3x vs lumiera/rline kaiski/derazor/d3x vs null/procore byce/Necrophag1st vs lumiera/rline byce/Necrophag1st vs null/procore Group 2 rook/Fastidious vs ulty/griff rook/Fastidious vs lonezilla/relay FFSmasher/v1ctor vs ulty/griff FFSmasher/v1ctor vs lonezilla/relay Group 3 dustin/gramz vs eldrek/duster dustin/gramz vs xero/wonko sane/grape/BlooD_DoG vs eldrek/duster sane/grape/BlooD_DoG vs xero/wonko Playoffs March 16th - April 5th (3 weeks) Top two teams from each group advance to single elimination brackets (seeded using record/frags to tie break) Please take screenshots of end game scores! Should be F12 by default in Steam. Upload to imgur. These servers are private and recording demos which can be retrieved. [NA]Chicago - 23.108.73.98:19964 [uS/TX] - 69.162.77.18:2154 There are also various servers with client limits of 4 that would be good for matches.
  17. Fastidious

    Will the item timers stay?

    I think most of us are fairly understanding but game forums tend towards extreme opinions. I'm mostly waiting around for teamplay modes and seeing what happens with those. I do miss the old newborn. The one who would frequently post long reasoning why things were done or his thoughts on random matters. That is one big reason I decided to invest some of my time and money in this project. I just feel a bit of a disconnect because when I read your posts newborn I agree with many of them deeply yet I am wondering why there haven't been more gameplay changes from someone who understands it so well. If Reflex is just going to be CPMA gameplay with some small tweaks I wish you'd tell us. That way I can stop reading the forum, stop buying copies and stop bugging my friends. I expected this project to go further than that. Push back on changes is not always a bad thing in the long run. It doesn't mean what the change intended to do was a bad idea but perhaps how it was accomplished and implemented. I've been playing competitive ArenaFPS a long time. I never liked how item timing worked that much either yet I also didn't care much for timers. Items feel too black and white; too limited. A player with good timing can swoop items. Picking up an item is all or nothing. There are no fine details, no nuances and no middle grounds. I think better changes would focus on the mechanics of items themselves instead of adding timers. Timers add free information but they do not touch the mechanics of items. Timing will always be in the game. Yet I want that timing to be more of the internal predatory sort. The timing of attacks and counter attacks. The timing of movement around a map route. Ambushes and races. Split second robot timing on items was never good gameplay yet it is impossible to extract from the game with the way items currently work.
  18. Fastidious

    some WILD ideas.

    Most of those I don't like but this type of thinking is what I expected out of Reflex, not just a tweaked CPMA version. I hope we still get fundamental changes which drastically alter mechanics. I like your item ideas best I think. I could post up a bunch of crazy ideas too but until the developers actually show a real willingness to break out from the Quake/CPMA mold more it seems pointless. I like randomness a lot but it is very sensitive to how you use it. For instance randomness in roguelike level generation is great but randomness on match time or item spawn time is terrible. Instead of having a random time on the clock; I like ideas such as a 5 capture limit in CTF more. It is predefined so it is something you can plan for and around. Yet it still has the same effect as it will vary match times.
  19. I think it is a cool offer but I'm not sure there is much market for it at $20 or even $15! When I was a the top of my competitive FPS games I spent at least 1/3 of my time analyzing my own or my teams (mostly my teams) demos so we could improve. If you are a competitive player who doesn't analyze demos you should start doing so. There is a lot of information out there you can pickup easily on your opponents or more importantly yourself or your team.
  20. Fastidious

    Will the item timers stay?

    As much as I hate to say this, until Reflex changes substantially gameplay wise it is going to be stuck in 'Quake'. That isn't a bad thing necessarily but while we know more changes are likely to come there is no guarantee Reflex will ever be significantly different than it is now either. This timer brouhaha is something you can easily imagine happening in a Quake game or competitive mod for Quake. I think for duel timers aren't that bad because they might get more newbies playing it but I think where they break down completely is TDM/CTF. Instead of arguing about timers or not I'd rather we completely changed game mechanics so exact time isn't needed. That would also break out from the Quake paradigm. I actually would recommend all those games to my friends if the games had active teamplay communities in NA. I've actually dragged a few friends into QW since setting up nQuake is rather painless and I think it is the best of the bunch. I've also recommended friends Reflex and bought copies for friends to support Reflex. I hope in the future to play teamplay modes in Reflex with friends. I think we might finally be reaching some catharsis on this issue of timers as a community.
  21. Fastidious

    mm suggestions

    Sounds way too complicated. Damage can mean little in TDM if players don't get in finishes to get the frag on the scoreboard. I'd say TDM is mostly about relative efficiency. Net frags or damage is important in comparison to the enemy team. While sacrifice plays a part of TDM, if a player is down -50 net frags they are almost certainly dragging the team down. That is not to say a player with -20 net frags can't be an overall positive contributor in TDM but the more frags and damage players are down in comparison to the enemy team the harder that is to pull off. The "garbage man" position in TDM is very important and usually no one wants to do it properly. It requires playing in weak positions, or sacrifice plays a lot of the time. Yet if this player plays well they will buoy the rest of their team up in relative frags/damage and lower the enemy team in the same. TDM is hard to break down and most of the glory usually goes to the quad/carnage runner but he depends heavily on the rest of his team to make his job easier or set him up. If the enemy players can be kept weak individually then as long as the quad/carnage runner is strong he should be able to mop them up even if the rest of his team is weak too. Yet "feeding" this one player is definitely a detriment to players own personal stats but often very good for the team as a whole.
  22. Fastidious

    New weapon concepts!

    Hint at upcoming gameplay changes? Sounds quite a bit different than what we have now!
  23. Fastidious

    Competitive Team-Mode possible?

    Wouldn't work with the way weapons are in Reflex. Reflex weapons are balanced for duel not TDM. Most weapons are similar in DPS and rockets aren't anywhere near as strong as QW rockets despite the "rocket is OP" crowd on the forum. This is mostly because QW rockets are strategic weapons that can cut off routes and spam very well. I think it is more realistic we'll see CTF or another new mode be the competitive team mode. I don't see TDM being a thing for Reflex unfortunately unless there are rather huge changes.
  24. Fastidious

    Ladder system vs no ladder system

    This is also one of my fears but there is still lots of work left for them to do. We can just wait and see what happens. I'm honestly not sure just being a slightly tweaked version of CPM is going to get Reflex enough players. CPM was a project to unite Q1-Q2-Q3 players but ended up not doing so. It took elements from each Quake but arguably was mostly QW influenced. CPM was never that popular but it had a decent scene for a while. I never bothered to play CPM during this time because I liked QW more and QW was massively more popular. During this same period many mod scenes were also going strong. That was age back when Quake was huge as whole. Regarding ladders; the coolest ladder trick I've seen in recent times was in SC2 where it limited showing only 100 players to compare against. So even if there was 1 million other guys around it didn't show them. It made it more personal and not so daunting. Of course most people probably know this now so it isn't quite a trick anymore.
  25. Fastidious

    mm suggestions

    Use duel elo even for non-duel play? What good would that do? Some players might never even duel at all.
×